Likely not, but definitely depends on the situation.
And how do you know the backup is not compromised?
I think it’s not as clear cut. It’s always a risk assessment and depends on context.
I have to say that I’m not a security expert, just an amateur with conceptual understanding of the topic and some opinions.
While I respect your right to express your opinion, I must state that your opinion is just as valid or void as the previous. I couldn’t know which. How would I?